A Lockout Locks Everyone Out

On December 1st, Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement with the players expires. Unless something changes fast, the 30 MLB owners l are going to do what everyone in the sport already expects: lock out the players. In their effort to pressure the players, however, MLB owners will hurt fans and taxpayers. If that happens, they should be forced to pay us back.

You’ll hear people call this a fight between billionaires and millionaires. Don’t buy it. That framing excludes everyone else who has a stake in the dispute, letting owners off the hook for their own decisions. The truth is simpler and uglier: a lockout is a choice, and only one side gets to make it. Players can’t lock anyone out. Fans can’t. The people who sell you a hot dog can’t. Thirty owners can, and they’re about to shut down a nearly $13 billion industry to try to get what they want.

What do they want? A players’ salary cap. They say it’s for you, the fans. It isn’t.

You paid for the house. Now they’re changing the locks.

Here’s the part that should make every taxpayer furious. These owners aren’t locking you out of their buildings. They’re locking you out of buildings you paid for.

By our count, state and local governments have handed MLB teams at least $6.5 billion in taxpayer-funded stadium subsidies since 2000. A sampling:

  • Yankees: $1.2 billion in public money for Yankee Stadium, the richest franchise in the sport.

  • Mets: $614 million for Citi Field.

  • Nationals: $611 million for Nationals Park, paid entirely by D.C.

  • Marlins: $510 million for LoanDepot park.

  • Rangers: $500 million for Globe Life Field, which opened in 2020.

  • Brewers: $500.8 million for renovations, on top of the public money that built the park in the first place.

And that’s the visible money. Since 2000, federal taxpayers have provided $3.2 billion in stadiums for pro stadiums through tax breaks on the bonds used to finance them. Hidden costs like infrastructure and tax breaks can push the public bill up another 25 to 40 percent.

Taxpayers should be incensed. Lawmakers backed a deal based on promises that games would be played, not that players would be locked out and a season cancelled. The public and our elected officials need to demand what we call a Lockout Clawback: owners paying back a share of their public construction subsidy for every home game canceled by a lockout. Spread that subsidy over 30 seasons of 81 home games, and you get a clawback per canceled game: 

  • Yankees: about $494,000 per canceled home game

  • Mets: about $253,000

  • Nationals: about $220,000

  • Marlins: about $210,000

  • Rangers: about $206,000

Across every team that took public money, a fully canceled season wastes roughly $236 million of taxpayer investment. These are conservative estimates: they count only construction money in unadjusted dollars. So for every game cancelled due to the lockout, MLB should write a check to the state or local government department of revenue to make taxpayers whole. Or better yet, let the players play ball!

The salary cap con

In May, the owners put their cards on the table: they demanded a hard cap of $245.3 million and a floor of $171.2 million, with industry revenue split 50-50 with players. MLB’s spokesman insists that fans overwhelmingly support it.

Here’s what they aren’t telling you. A salary cap targets one thing: what players earn. It does not lower ticket prices or the price of beer. It doesn’t make streaming services more affordable on game day. A cap on players’ income just redirects their earnings into owners’ pockets. Not one cent comes back to you, the fan.

The players’ union estimates that if the owners’ plan had been in effect this year, players would have lost more than half a billion dollars. Ask yourself where that money goes. Hint: it adds a zero to the owners' net worth.

And don’t think the squeeze stops at players. Owners who want to cap their star players are the same owners who watch their stadium workers walk off the job. Fenway Park’s concession workers went on strike in 2025. Dodger Stadium’s workers voted 99 percent to authorize a strike before the 2022 All-Star Game. Owners who cap players’ pay will keep shortchanging the workers who make game day special for fans.

A lockout locks everyone out

Every big-league game takes an army. The Mets require 1,800 game-day staff at Citi Field. At Dodger Stadium, the concession contractor alone employs nearly 1,500 workers. Ushers, cooks, beer vendors, security guards, janitors, groundskeepers, broadcast crews. Multiply that across 30 ballparks and 81 home games.

These aren’t millionaires. These are working class jobs. When a game is canceled, a shift is gone. There’s no back pay.

We’ve seen this movie. During the last lockout, it was the players, together with the AFL-CIO, who launched a $1 million fund for the stadium workers losing paychecks. Owners locked out workers; the players paid them. So ask yourself: who’s really advocating for the people who make your game day happen?

So, in addition to the Lockout Clawback for taxpayers, owners should be forced to pay the salaries of stadium workers who otherwise stand to lose their livelihoods during the lockout.

A lockout doesn’t only hurt stadium workers. The bartender at the sports bar down the street loses tips. The freelance photographer loses assignments. Before the last lockout, the manager of a bar near Nationals Park predicted crowds would fall 50 to 75 percent until baseball came back.


Economists might argue that people will just direct their money elsewhere. Consumer spending may shift , but the usher will remain unpaid. These workers, who are essential to making the game-day experience special, have no say in the matter. They are subject to the whims of billionaires.

So, in addition to the Lockout Clawback and stadium workers’ pay, owners should be forced to pay a make-good to local businesses that stand to lose money due to a lockout.

Blackouts: the lockout fans already live with

If you want to know how much the owners care about fans, look at how they treat the ones watching from home.

Fans across the country already know what it feels like to be locked out. Every season, local TV blackouts prevent people from watching their own team, often on a streaming service they’ve paid for. MLB itself calls local blackouts a top fan concern.

So, what’s the league’s plan to fix it? It’s bundled into the salary cap proposal. The media reform that would address blackouts is part of the same package, and every concession the owners offer is contingent on players accepting a cap.

MLB admits that blackouts hurt fans, but its sympathy only extends so far. 

Nothing about ending blackouts depends on a salary cap. It requires MLB to want to end them. And Congress has leverage here: baseball’s antitrust exemption, a century-old legal privilege that no other sport enjoys, still covers broadcasting contracts. If the league won’t free the games, lawmakers can start asking why it deserves that special treatment.

What fans should demand

The owners are counting on fans to tune out until it’s over. Don’t. Here’s what Sports Fans Coalition is demanding, and what you should demand too:

  1. Full refunds, with interest. Every ticket, season-ticket deposit and parking pass for a canceled game gets refunded, with interest. Owners don’t get to hold your money while they hold the season hostage.

  2. End blackouts now, no strings attached. If MLB can fix local blackouts, it can do it today, not as a bargaining chip.

  3. The Lockout Clawback. Every state and city that subsidized a ballpark should demand a refund for every home game the owners cancel. You paid for the house. If they lock you out, they owe you rent.

  4. Workers’ compensation. Every stadium employee and local business that stands to lose their livelihoods due to a lockout should be made whole.

To lawmakers who voted for those stadium deals: take note. Team owners took your constituents’ money and promised both jobs and economic growth. Now, they are about to padlock the gates to keep more for themselves. Remember that the next time an owner asks for public funding for a new ballpark or a renovation.

This was never billionaires versus millionaires. It’s 30 owners versus everyone else: the fans who fill the seats, the workers who make the game happen, the taxpayers who built the stadiums, and yes, the players who play the game.

A lockout locks everyone out. Sports Fans Coalition stands with every one of them.

Next
Next

SFC Applauds Ninth Circuit Decision Reinstating Sunday Ticket Jury Verdict Against the NFL